Sample Escalation Procedures Decision Rights

Sample_Documents

DISCLAIMER: This is a sample template provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Organizations should consult their own legal and tax advisors and tailor this document to reflect their specific business needs, geographies, and applicable laws.

Escalation Procedures & Decision Rights

• Company: <Company Name>
• Document Type: Escalation Procedures & Decision Rights
• Category: Communication & Administration
• Version: <Version Number> (e.g., 1.0)
• Effective Date: <Date>
• Next Scheduled Review: <Date> (e.g., 12 months from Effective Date)
• Document Owner: <Total Rewards Leader Title> (e.g., Head of Total Rewards)
• Process Owner: <Title> (e.g., Director, Compensation Operations)
• Approver(s): <Executive Sponsor Title> (e.g., CHRO), <Finance Leader>, <Legal Counsel>
• Applies To: Global Total Rewards, HR, Payroll, HRIS/People Technology, People Managers, and vendors supporting <Company Name>
• Confidentiality: Internal Use Only
• Supersedes: <Prior Document Name and Date>
• Related Policies and Standards: <Delegation of Authority Policy>, <Compensation Philosophy>, <Bonus Plan Rules>, <Equity Administration Guidelines>, <Data Privacy Policy>

Document Purpose and Objectives

• Provide a clear, repeatable approach for escalating, triaging, and resolving Total Rewards issues and decisions across <Company Name>.
• Define decision rights and approval thresholds for compensation, benefits, equity, and recognition programs, including exceptions.
• Establish service levels, controls, documentation standards, and communication protocols that protect employees, reduce risk, and sustain operational excellence.
• Align with <Company Name>’s values, <Country> legal requirements, and external audit expectations.

Scope and Applicability

• In Scope
  • Compensation programs: base pay, merit, promotions, market adjustments, offers, and off-cycle corrections.
  • Variable pay: annual bonus, sales incentive, spot awards, and discretionary adjustments.
  • Equity: time-based and performance-based awards, refresh grants, and exceptions.
  • Benefits: health and welfare escalations, leave pay coordination, retirement plan corrections, and claim appeals.
  • Payroll and HRIS: pay-impacting system defects, payroll errors, and data fixes.
  • Vendor-related issues: service outages, data breaches, SLA failures, and invoice disputes.
  • Compliance: regulatory reporting, tax treatment of rewards, plan governance, and audit findings.
• Out of Scope
  • Employee relations investigations unrelated to pay or benefits (handled by <Employee Relations Team>).
  • Routine HR inquiries resolved at Tier 0/Tier 1 without escalation.
  • Performance management decisions not tied to compensation or benefits eligibility.
  • Enterprise-wide incident response outside Total Rewards domain (handled by <Enterprise Incident Management>).

Guiding Principles

• Employee-first: Protect employees’ pay and benefits by prioritizing issues that impact well-being or legal compliance.
• Right decision, right level: Empower decision-makers closest to the data within clear limits; escalate when threshold, risk, or complexity warrants.
• Speed with control: Resolve quickly while maintaining required approvals and documentation.
• Transparency: Communicate status, decisions, and rationales to stakeholders in plain language.
• Data privacy: Limit access to sensitive information to authorized roles only and follow <Country> data protection laws.
• Auditability: Maintain an evidence trail sufficient for internal and external audit.

Definitions and Severity Model

Key Definitions

• Escalation: The process of raising an issue or decision to a higher authority or specialized team when it cannot be resolved at the current level, requires additional approvals, exceeds thresholds, or presents heightened risk.
• Decision Rights: The formally assigned authority to make a decision within defined parameters (amount, percentage, policy domain, geography).
• Exception: A deviation from approved policy, plan rules, or standard process that requires documented approval.
• Triage: The initial assessment to classify severity, confirm scope, and route the issue to the correct owner.
• SLA: Service Level Agreement for response, communication, workaround, and resolution time targets.

Severity Levels and Service Targets

Severity	Definition	Examples (Illustrative)	Acknowledge Target	Workaround Target	Resolution Target	Communication Cadence
P1 Critical	Immediate risk to pay or benefits for many employees, legal/regulatory exposure, or data breach	Payroll file failure affecting ><Number> employees, bonus payout miscalculation > <Amount>, inadvertent disclosure of HR data	1 business hour	4 business hours	24 hours	Hourly until stable, then twice daily
P2 High	Significant impact to a population or a high-risk decision; deadlines within <Number> days	Equity grant load error, benefits eligibility misapplied for > <Number> employees	4 business hours	1 business day	3 business days	Daily
P3 Moderate	Limited population impact; time-sensitive but not urgent	Single-country market adjustment exceptions, localized payroll correction < Amount >	1 business day	3 business days	10 business days	Twice weekly
P4 Low	Individual or non-urgent inquiry; no immediate financial impact	Individual claim appeal, job leveling clarification	2 business days	As needed	20 business days	Weekly

Severity Assignment Notes

• Use the highest severity that reasonably fits the impact, legal risk, or time sensitivity.
• Reassess and downgrade or upgrade severity as new information emerges.
• When in doubt, classify as higher severity and reassess within <Number> hours.

Decision Rights Framework

Principles for Decision Rights

• Decisions are made by the lowest appropriate level with adequate expertise and authority.
• Approval thresholds combine amount (e.g., <Amount>), percentage (e.g., <Percentage> above midpoint or target), population (e.g., > <Number> employees), and risk (e.g., regulatory, public company reporting).
• Co-approvals are required when decisions cross functional boundaries (e.g., Total Rewards and Finance for spend; Legal for compliance risk).
• Delegations must be explicit, time-bound, and documented; no implied or retroactive delegations.
• Exceptions are documented with business rationale, alternatives considered, and impact assessment (cost, precedent, pay equity).

Standard Approval Thresholds (Customize)

• People Manager: up to <Percentage> within range guidelines; no exceptions beyond policy without HRBP.
• HRBP: up to <Percentage> above range or <Amount> total cost; exceptions require Total Rewards review.
• Total Rewards Manager: up to <Percentage> above range or <Amount>; requires Finance co-approval if budget variance > <Percentage>.
• Head of Total Rewards: up to <Amount> aggregate cost or program rule interpretation; Legal co-approval for compliance risk.
• CHRO: strategic exceptions, program rule waivers, or aggregate spend > <Amount>; CFO co-approval for funding impacts.
• CEO/Board or Compensation Committee: equity plan amendments, executive pay exceptions, or aggregate change > <Amount>.

Decision Rights Matrix (Illustrative)

Issue Type	Decision Owner	Authority Limit (Customize)	Required Co-Approvals	Escalation Path	Notes
Base pay adjustment within range	People Manager with HRBP	Up to <Percentage> of midpoint	None if within budget; Finance if budget variance	HRBP → Total Rewards	Align to pay equity guardrails
Promotion increase	HRBP with Total Rewards	Up to <Percentage> increase or <Amount>	Finance if off-cycle budget	Total Rewards Director → Head of TR	Review internal parity and compression
Offer above max range	Total Rewards Director	Up to <Percentage> above range or <Amount>	HRBP, Finance, Legal (as needed)	Head of TR → CHRO	Document market justification
Annual bonus plan rule interpretation	Head of TR	N/A	Legal, Finance	CHRO → Compensation Committee	Use plan documents for precedence
Discretionary bonus outside plan	Head of TR	Up to <Amount> per employee	Finance	CHRO → CEO	Consider clawback rules if applicable
Equity grant exception	Head of TR	Up to <Amount> fair value	Legal, Finance	CHRO → Compensation Committee	Requires plan capacity check
Payroll correction > threshold	Payroll Director with TR	Up to <Amount> per pay period	Finance	Head of TR → CHRO	Communicate to impacted employees
Benefits claim appeal (final level)	Benefits Leader	Policy-bound	Legal (if ERISA/related)	Head of TR → CHRO	Follow plan documents and local law
Market data override	Compensation Manager	+/- <Percentage> from model output	Head of TR (if outside)	Head of TR → CHRO	Maintain survey references
Job level/grade dispute	HRBP with Compensation	Within leveling framework	Head of TR (if exception)	CHRO	Document job architecture mapping
Vendor service outage decision	TR Ops Lead	N/A	IT Security, Legal, Vendor Mgmt	Head of TR → CIO/CHRO	Trigger incident response if P1
HRIS security incident (TR data)	CISO with TR	N/A	Legal, Privacy, Comms	CIO → CHRO/CEO	Follow breach notification laws
International assignment allowance exception	Global Mobility Lead	Up to <Amount> or <Percentage> of package	Tax, Legal, Finance	Head of TR → CHRO	Consider tax gross-up policy

Escalation Procedures

When to Escalate

• The issue meets P1 or P2 severity criteria or time-sensitive deadlines (e.g., payroll cutoffs, grant dates).
• The decision exceeds the requestor’s authority limit or requires cross-functional co-approval.
• There is a disagreement among stakeholders that cannot be resolved within <Number> business days.
• The request involves potential non-compliance with laws, plan documents, or audit findings.
• A vendor is not meeting contracted SLAs and impacts employee pay or benefits.

How to Log an Escalation

• Submit a case in <System Name> using the category Total Rewards Escalation.
• Include the following minimum data:
  • Requester name, title, and contact.
  • Business unit, country, impacted population size, and employee IDs (as applicable).
  • Clear description, desired outcome, and deadline.
  • Severity level proposed and rationale.
  • Attachments: screenshots, files, plan documents, calculations, and prior approvals.
• For P1 issues, additionally call the on-call number <Phone Number> and tag @TR-OnCall in <Collaboration Tool>.

Triage and Routing

1. Confirm receipt and set initial severity within the Acknowledge Target.
2. Validate scope, impacted population, and deadlines; update severity if needed.
3. Identify the decision owner based on the Decision Rights Matrix.
4. Engage required co-approvers (Finance, Legal, HRBP) and notify affected stakeholders.
5. Create an action plan with tasks, owners, and timelines; record in <System Name>.

Investigation and Root Cause

1. Gather data from HRIS, payroll, benefits administrators, and market sources.
2. Replicate calculations and reconcile to source-of-truth systems.
3. Assess legal, tax, and plan document constraints; consult Legal/Tax as needed.
4. Evaluate alternatives, cost, precedent, pay equity, and employee experience.
5. Document root cause, control gaps, and corrective actions.

Resolution and Approval

1. Prepare a decision summary including background, analysis, recommendation, costs, and risks.
2. Obtain approvals per thresholds and record approver names, dates, and comments.
3. Implement the decision (e.g., adjust pay in HRIS, update payroll, instruct vendor).
4. Validate results in downstream systems and confirm with requestor and HRBP.
5. If applicable, communicate outcome to employees and managers with required disclosures.

Closure and Documentation

1. Close the case in <System Name> with final severity, resolution code, and timestamps.
2. Store evidence: calculations, approvals, communications, and vendor tickets.
3. Create or update knowledge articles for recurring issues.
4. Log control failures and open corrective actions with owners and due dates.

Examples of Common Escalations (Illustrative)

• Merit Cycle Error (P2): A country file shows a formula error causing <Percentage> over-budget. Escalate to Compensation Ops; Finance co-approval required for budget adjustment or re-run.
• Offer Above Range (P3): A critical hire in <Country> requires an offer at <Percentage> above max. Total Rewards Director decision with HRBP and Finance co-approvals; create exception memo.
• Equity Load Failure (P1): Equity vendor <Vendor Name> rejects grant file on grant date. Engage TR Ops, IT, and vendor; acknowledge in 1 hour; workaround within 4 hours; complete load within 24 hours; update CHRO hourly.
• Benefits Claim Appeal (P4 to P3): An employee appeals an out-of-network claim denial. Benefits Leader reviews plan document and local law; Legal consult if required; decision within 10 business days.
• Payroll Correction (P2): Missed retro pay > <Amount> affecting > <Number> employees. Payroll Director executes off-cycle run; Finance sign-off on funding; employees notified within 1 business day.

Roles and Responsibilities

Total Rewards (TR)

• Owns decision rights framework, thresholds, and exception governance.
• Leads triage for compensation, equity, and benefits escalations.
• Ensures pay equity, internal parity, and compliance with plan documents.
• Maintains documentation, metrics, and continuous improvement actions.

HR Business Partners (HRBP)

• First-line advisors for managers; submit and advocate escalations when needed.
• Validate business rationale, headcount, and organizational impact.
• Ensure manager accountability for following policy and process.

People Managers

• Resolve within guidance when inside authority limits.
• Provide timely and accurate data to support escalations.
• Communicate decisions to employees using approved messages.

Payroll

• Executes pay corrections and off-cycle payments within SLAs.
• Reconciles payroll entries to HRIS and Finance.
• Maintains audit evidence for all corrections.

HRIS/People Technology

• Investigates system defects, configuration issues, and data integrations.
• Implements fixes and regression tests; coordinates release timing with TR and Payroll.
• Ensures role-based access controls protect sensitive data.

Benefits Team

• Coordinates with <Vendor Name> and third-party administrators on appeals and corrections.
• Ensures compliance with plan documents and local regulations in <Country>.
• Tracks vendor SLAs and escalates service failures.

Finance

• Reviews budget impact, accruals, and funding sources.
• Co-approves monetary exceptions and program changes per Delegation of Authority.
• Supports audit readiness and financial controls.

Legal/Compliance/Privacy

• Advises on regulatory, contractual, and data privacy requirements.
• Reviews high-risk exceptions, plan interpretations, and disclosures.
• Coordinates with Internal Audit on control effectiveness and remediation.

Employee Relations and Internal Audit

• ER addresses conduct/behavioral issues separate from TR decisioning.
• Internal Audit tests controls, reviews exception documentation, and issues findings.

Vendor Partners

• Provide timely root-cause analysis, remediation, and credits if SLAs are missed.
• Maintain secure handling of <Company Name> data in alignment with contracts and law.
• Participate in joint post-incident reviews when P1/P2 events occur.

Service Levels, Metrics, and Controls

Service Level Commitments (Targets)

• Initial acknowledgement within SLA by severity (see table).
• Regular updates per communication cadence until closure.
• Root-cause analysis and corrective action plan for all P1/P2 issues within <Number> business days of resolution.
• Off-cycle payroll for pay-impacting corrections exceeding <Amount> within <Number> business days, subject to banking cutoffs.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

• Percentage of escalations acknowledged within SLA: target > <Percentage>.
• Percentage resolved within SLA: target > <Percentage>.
• Reopen rate within 30 days: target < Percentage >.
• Average time to resolution by severity.
• Number of exceptions by type and business unit; trend vs. prior quarter.
• Vendor SLA attainment rate: target > <Percentage>.

Control Activities

• Dual-approval for payments exceeding <Amount> or <Percentage> over policy.
• Segregation of duties between requestor, approver, and processor.
• Periodic access reviews for TR, Payroll, and HRIS roles.
• Quarterly spot checks of exception memos for completeness.
• Annual tabletop exercises for P1 incident response with <Vendor Name> and IT.

Simple RACI Snapshot (Illustrative)

Activity	Requestor	HRBP	Total Rewards	Payroll	Finance	Legal
Pay correction > <Amount>	R	C	A	R	C	I
Offer above range	R	C	A	I	C	I
Equity exception	I	C	A	I	C	C
Benefits appeal final	R	I	C	I	I	A

Legend: R = Responsible, A = Accountable, C = Consulted, I = Informed

Compliance, Risk, and Privacy Considerations

Legal and Regulatory

• Decisions must comply with all applicable laws in <Country> and each jurisdiction where employees work, including wage and hour, equal pay, tax withholding, and securities regulations.
• Plan rules govern bonus and equity; deviations require documented rationale and required approvals.
• Ensure compliance with works council or union agreements where applicable.

Data Privacy and Security

• Access to employee compensation and benefits data is restricted to authorized roles; follow least-privilege principles.
• Transmit data using approved secure channels only; do not email unencrypted PII or HR data.
• Follow incident response procedures for suspected data breaches; coordinate with Privacy and Security teams.

Audit and Documentation Retention

• Retain exception memos, approvals, and supporting evidence for at least <Number> years or as required by law.
• Maintain change logs for system configuration and calculation models.
• Ensure evidence is accessible for Internal Audit and external auditors on request.

Implementation Guidelines

Preparation and Enablement

• Configure <System Name> categories, fields, and routing rules for Total Rewards escalations.
• Load decision rights thresholds and approver lists; review quarterly.
• Set up on-call rotations for P1/P2 coverage with clear escalation phone trees.

Training and Adoption

• Provide role-based training:
  • Managers and HRBP: when and how to escalate, authority limits.
  • TR, Payroll, HRIS: triage, investigation, and documentation standards.
  • Finance and Legal: co-approval workflows and evidence expectations.
• Publish short job aids and sample exception memos with placeholders.

Operating Rhythm

• Weekly TR Operations standup to review open P2/P3 escalations.
• Monthly metrics review with CHRO staff; highlight trends and systemic fixes.
• Quarterly vendor reviews to assess SLA performance and credit eligibility.
• Semi-annual simulation of P1 scenarios to validate readiness.

Exception Memo Template (Outline)

1. Background and request summary.
2. Policy/plan references and constraints.
3. Data and analysis, including cost and equity impact.
4. Options considered and risks.
5. Recommendation and business rationale.
6. Approvals: names, titles, dates, and limits.
7. Implementation steps and controls.
8. Post-implementation validation plan.

Review and Approval Process

Governance

• The Document Owner ensures the content remains current with policy changes, organizational structure, and regulatory updates.
• Proposed changes follow this approval path:

1. Draft by Total Rewards
2. Review by HRIS, Payroll, HRBP representatives
3. Legal and Finance review for compliance and fiscal impact
4. CHRO approval; Compensation Committee brief if executive pay implications

Review Cycle

• Effective Date: <Date>.
• Scheduled Review: at least annually or upon material change to programs, systems, or regulations.
• Versioning: increment version upon approved updates; maintain change log with summary and date.

Change Log (Example Structure)

Version	Date	Summary of Changes	Author	Approver
1.0	<Date>	Initial release	<Name>	<Name/Title>
1.1	<Date>	Updated thresholds and severity definitions	<Name>	<Name/Title>

Glossary of Terms

• Accrual: Accounting estimate of expense recognized before payment is made.
• Clawback: Company right to recover compensation under specified conditions.
• Delegation of Authority (DoA): Policy that defines approval levels and spending limits.
• Fair Value: Accounting measure for equity award valuation on grant date.
• Midpoint: Market-aligned reference point of a pay range.
• Pay Compression: Minimal pay differences among employees regardless of experience or performance.
• PII: Personally identifiable information.
• Workaround: Temporary fix to reduce impact while permanent resolution is in progress.

Communication Section: How Employees and Managers Get Help

Purpose of this Section

• This section is written for employees and managers. It explains what to do if you have a pay or benefits concern, how quickly you can expect a response, and who is responsible for decisions.

If You Have a Pay or Benefits Concern

• Start by checking available resources in <Help Center Name> for step-by-step guides on topics like pay statements, bonus plans, and benefits.
• If you still need help, submit a request in <System Name> using the category Total Rewards. Be sure to include:
  • Your full name and employee ID.
  • A description of the issue and what you believe the correct outcome should be.
  • Any deadlines, such as payroll cutoffs or benefit enrollment dates.
  • Screenshots or documents that help explain the situation.

What Happens After You Submit

• You will receive a confirmation that your request was received. For urgent issues affecting pay or benefits for multiple people, we treat these as high priority.
• A specialist will review your request, classify how urgent it is, and contact you if more information is needed.
• We will keep you informed of progress. For urgent cases, you may receive updates as frequently as every few hours. For most cases, you will receive updates at least weekly until the issue is resolved.

When Issues Are Escalated

• Some requests require additional approvals or review by Legal, Finance, or other teams. This is normal and helps ensure we follow policies and laws.
• If your request involves an exception to a policy or an amount beyond normal guidelines, it will be reviewed by senior leaders in Total Rewards and, when needed, the CHRO.

Typical Timeframes

• We aim to acknowledge requests within 1 to 2 business days for most issues, faster for urgent pay-impacting matters.
• Resolution times vary depending on complexity and whether other teams or external vendors are involved. For example:
  • Payroll corrections may be handled in the next payroll or via an off-cycle payment when appropriate.
  • Benefits claim appeals can take several days to a few weeks depending on the plan and the vendor’s review.

Your Role as a Manager

• Please review and resolve items within your authority using the guidance provided in <Manager Guide Name>.
• When submitting an escalation, include business context, budget information, and any prior approvals. This helps us resolve quickly.
• Communicate with your employee about timelines and next steps using the talking points we provide.

Our Commitment to You

• We strive to be accurate, fair, and responsive. If we make a mistake, we will fix it and let you know what happened and how we will prevent it in the future.
• Your personal information is handled confidentially and only shared with those who need it to resolve the issue.

Contact Options

• <System Name> case submission for all requests.
• For urgent payroll-impacting issues, call <Phone Number> during business hours.
• For benefits emergencies, contact <Vendor Name> at <Vendor Phone> and submit a case so we can follow up.

Final Notes

• This overview does not change policy or plan rules. If there is any difference between this overview and a plan document or policy, the plan document or policy controls.
• If you have questions about how decisions are made, you can ask your HR Business Partner or include your question in your case. We will respond and, when helpful, share the relevant policy reference.

Appendix: Quick Reference

Severity Quick Guide

• P1 Critical: Major pay/benefits risk or legal exposure; we respond within about 1 hour and work continuously until resolved.
• P2 High: Significant impact or tight deadlines; we respond same day and aim to resolve in a few days.
• P3 Moderate: Limited impact; we respond within 1 business day and resolve within about 2 weeks.
• P4 Low: Individual or informational; we respond within 2 business days and resolve within about 3 weeks.

Who Decides What (Summary)

• Managers: Decisions within policy and budget.
• HRBP: Advises managers; approves limited exceptions.
• Total Rewards: Owns most exceptions and policy interpretations.
• Finance and Legal: Co-approve when money or compliance risks are involved.
• CHRO/Committee: Highest-level exceptions and executive-related matters.

Effective Date and Review Reminder

• Effective Date: <Date>
• Next Review: <Date>
• For feedback or suggested improvements, contact <Distribution List or Owner Email>.

---

Document Information:

• Document Type: Escalation Procedures & Decision Rights
• Category: Communication & Administration
• Generated: August 28, 2025
• Status: Sample Template
• Next Review: <Insert Review Date>

Usage Instructions:

1. Replace all text in angle brackets < > with your company-specific information
2. Review all sections for applicability to your organization
3. Customize content to reflect your company's policies and local regulations
4. Have legal and HR leadership review before implementation
5. Update document header with your company's version control information
6. At bottom of the document you find a short example on how the content could be communicated to end-users, for instance employees.

This sample document is provided for reference only and should be customized to meet your organization's specific needs and local legal requirements.